by Joyce Carol Oats
It took me a while to read this novel. Because of its VERY heavy subject matter, I had to take a good, long break between reading sessions. Not because it wasn’t incredibly engaging, but because I couldn’t sit with the incredibly “icky” feeling that would sit and grow in the pit of my stomach, but then again, most of Joyce Carol Oats’ writing makes me feel unsettled. She does not tiptoe around issues and immerses her readers in this psychological web of disturbed characters.
Everyone loves Mr Fox. He is a romantic, dashing English teacher who recites poetry. All the adolescent girls in his class adore him, and each feels especially special if chosen for his “Looking Glass Bookclub.” However, as his name implies, Mr Fox is a sexual predator who preys on his students. He is selective with the students for his club: they must be pretty and come from wealthy, powerful families.
One morning, a damaged car is found stuck in a bog. Inside is the mutilated body of Mr Fox.
Who could have killed him? Was it the Headmistress who had a crush and discovered his secret? Or a parent, seeking revenge for their daughter’s trauma? The detective faces many suspects.
As the story progresses, more secrets are revealed, revealing a dark side of human nature.
Oats mostly writes in the first person, placing us in the minds of various characters, including Mr Fox. Spending time inside the mind of a serial paedophile is incredibly taxing, so reader beware.
This novel explores class, exploitation, secrets, lies, and half-truths. Every character is deeply flawed. It’s hard to find any redeeming qualities among them.
Even though Joyce Carol Oates often writes on difficult topics, she is one of my favourite authors. Her talent with prose (she shows rather than tells) snares the reader until the end, when she releases you, unsettled.
Obvious trigger warnings for child sexual abuse.
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House for the copy.




